| Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BLASKO, Derek | SO | Southern Virginia | 47.43m | 2017 W&L Carnival |
| 2 | CLARONI, Daniel | SR | Washington and Lee | 40.00m | |
| 3 | DAVIS, Devon | SO | Randolph | 36.59m | 2017 Liberty Collegiate Invite |
| 4 | CARTER, Quordel | SO | Randolph | NM | |
| 5 | JONES, Robert | SR | Washington and Lee | NM |